When I was checking in to the ER on Tuesday one of the questions I was asked in registration was what my religious preference was. I quickly responded, “atheist,” but what I was thinking was, “Why the hell does that matter? I’m here with an allergic reaction. You are wasting time asking me what I believe, when the only thing that maters right now is what might kill me!” But I kept my mouth shut because I was a little more worried about my throat closing up on me and I sure didn’t want to waste any more time.
I took a class in college on hospital chaplaincy, so I understand that religious hospitals (the one’s in Boise are Catholic) want to know if they should administer last rites if you’re about to die or what denomination’s minister to call in if you find yourself in need of someone to talk to. However, I was in the EMERGENCY ROOM, I didn’t need a pastor or priest, I needed a doctor. Save my life first, then you can worry about my nonexistent soul.
While we’re on the topic of Catholic Hospitals, I’m sure a lot of you saw in the news that St. Joseph’s Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix has been stripped of it’s church affiliation by Bishop Thomas Olmstead, a decision that was seconded by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. What grievous thing did the hospital do?
In November 2009, a 27-year-old mother of four in her third month of pregnancy arrived at St. Joseph’s. She was diagnosed with pulmonary hypertension, a serious complication that might well have killed her if she had continued the pregnancy.
The hospital performed an abortion…
Let’s weigh the options here:
Option 1: Follow Church Doctrine
- Mother dies.
- Pregnancy is terminated.
- Four children left motherless.
Option 2: Abort
- Mother lives.
- Pregnancy is terminated.
- Four children get to keep their mother.
Honestly I’m not sure if this bishop needs a heart or a brain…
Obviously the hospital did the right thing. However, what if the hospital had refused the abortion on religious grounds?
I cherish religious (and anti-religious) liberty, but what happens when beliefs can kill? Should the state have the right to force hospitals and doctors to perform life saving procedures that are against their religious beliefs?
I’m torn on this one. Let’s hash it out in the comments.
Recent Comments